An illustrated food blog · New York City · Five boroughs by fork

The Nearest Table · est. 2026

The Nearest Table

The best Italian restaurant near me, answered corner by corner — a guide to Italian New York by subway stop and walk radius, every detail checked against the restaurant’s own pages.

Dispatch · Sep 21

Italian Restaurants Near the Gramercy Park Hotel

Priya Raman · September 21, 2026 · Updated October 7, 2026 · 3 min

Two verified Italian kitchens sit within a few minutes' walk of the Gramercy Park Hotel building at 2 Lexington Avenue, with hours re-checked in October 2026.

Using the Gramercy Park Hotel at 2 Lexington Avenue as your starting point? Two verified Italian kitchens sit within about three blocks of the building, both reachable on foot in under ten minutes. Here’s what’s open, sorted by walking distance from the hotel’s front door on 21st Street.

Quick Answer

Maialino is not currently an option: as of October 2026, Maialino’s own website says the restaurant “has closed its doors at The Redbury Hotel” and lists no current location. The two closest verified Italian kitchens are Novità and Giorgio’s of Gramercy, within a three-block walk west on 22nd and 21st Streets. The nearest subway is the 6 train at 23rd Street–Park Avenue South, about a five-minute walk from the hotel entrance.

At a Glance

  • Closest walk, old-school Gramercy room: Novità, 102 East 22nd Street
  • Best for a private table or small group: Giorgio’s of Gramercy, 27 East 21st Street
  • Nearest subway: 6 train, 23rd Street–Park Avenue South

Novità: Three Minutes West

A short walk west to 22nd Street, Novità has run a Gramercy trattoria at 102 East 22nd Street since 1994. It’s a below-street-level dining room known for regional Italian dishes, including a classic tagliolini bolognese. As of October 2026, its site lists lunch Monday through Friday from noon to 3:30pm and dinner every night from 5 to 10pm, with weekends dinner only.

Giorgio’s of Gramercy: Four Minutes West

One block further, at 27 East 21st Street where Gramercy meets Flatiron, Giorgio’s of Gramercy has been serving handmade pasta and running a private event space since 1992. As of October 2026, its site lists hours of noon to 10pm Monday through Wednesday, noon to 11pm Thursday and Friday, 5 to 11pm Saturday, and 5 to 10pm Sunday.

Getting There: Subway and Walking Notes

The 6 train’s 23rd Street–Park Avenue South station is the closest subway stop to both restaurants, roughly a five-minute walk from the hotel. Coming from other lines, the N/Q/R/W and 4/5/6 at 14th Street–Union Square is about ten minutes on foot north along Park Avenue South. For a longer stay in the neighborhood, a block-by-block look at Park Avenue South covers what’s between Union Square and Gramercy Park beyond these two rooms, and a date-night guide to Gramercy’s bar and booth seating is useful if the visit is for a specific occasion rather than a quick dinner. For more rooms around the park itself, where to eat near Gramercy Park, corner by corner sorts the options by which corner you set off from.

Neither of these rooms is affiliated with this publication — they’re simply the closest verified options to the hotel’s front door, which is the point of this list.

Check each restaurant’s current hours before heading over, since they can shift seasonally.

Frequently asked questions

Is Maialino still open at the Gramercy Park Hotel?

No. As of October 2026, Maialino’s own website says the restaurant has closed its doors at The Redbury Hotel, and it lists no current address. The closest verified Italian kitchens to the Gramercy Park Hotel are Novità on East 22nd Street and Giorgio’s of Gramercy on East 21st Street, both a few minutes’ walk west.

Is there an Italian restaurant near the Gramercy Park Hotel that doesn’t require a reservation?

Novità and Giorgio’s of Gramercy both run traditional table service, and given their small dining rooms, calling ahead is the safer move on a weekend. Giorgio’s is open straight through from noon on weekdays, which leaves the most room for an unplanned weekday meal. Checking availability with either one by phone is more reliable than a same-day walk-in.

What subway stop is closest to the Gramercy Park Hotel?

The 6 train at 23rd Street–Park Avenue South, roughly a five-minute walk from the hotel entrance and the closest stop to both restaurants in this guide. From the N/Q/R/W and 4/5/6 at 14th Street–Union Square, the walk is about ten minutes along Park Avenue South.

↑ Back to dispatches

Postcards from the road

One dispatch in your inbox when a new field note is published — routes, itineraries and vetting intel.

no spam — just the good tables.